Object
- Closes #260 while two of its four bullets are undone. The card asks for auto-deploy of main and the test runner in CI. The PR body says both are not done, and the diff only adds…
Object (not a verdict on the code; I could not review the change)
- The
# Diffsection is empty, so I cannot check PLAN_PROMPT, the Depends-on writer inplan_spec, or the test changes…
Approve
time.py:783-788: I tracedparallel()through every case in the new tests. "5"→5, "1"→1, "0"→3 (theor 3catches the zero), "-2"→3, "abc"→3 (ValueError), "2.5"→3…
Object
- The concurrency DONE criterion is not met.
createRun(runs.js:20-21) checksactive:${visitor}and then writes it in a separate step. KV has no compare-and-set, so two…
Approve
quc/src/worker.js:78:crypto.randomUUID()exists only in secure contexts (HTTPS or localhost). Submitting from a plain-HTTP non-localhost origin would throw and the form would…
Approve
I reviewed the diff against card #202 and did not run the tests myself. The only check on the head commit is ci / test, which is green.
- time.py:574-604:
think()now returns…
Object. I can't approve this because the diff section is empty, so I can't check any line in .github/time/astra.py or test_time.py.
What I could check from the PR description and…
Approve
The diff does what card #198 asks: the sweep lists open cards that a card closed in the last 30 days appears to have done, with the closing card's number, and it closes and labels…
Object
The rules core is mostly sound, but I found a real bypass of the desk's rules, a changelog that claims unshipped behaviour, and test counts that disagree. The diff is also cut off…
Object
The rules and tests look careful, and nothing in the visible diff creates anything on Whop, but three paths that the finish line depends on look broken. The diff is also cut off…
Approve
The diff does what card #173 asks: spine cards with a DONE: line are ranked and shown, never picked, never cloud-sent, never in the promotion order, and never labelled. The label…
Object
The CI check is green, but the ledger rule doesn't match the card's "one dominant route yields one candidate" requirement.
router.py:ledger_candidates(the…
Approve
The change matches card #172: one settled line per live pick, the spend proxy is stated and documented, the venture day-7 count is in, and the summary header is wired into Astra's…
Approve, with two non-blocking follow-ups.
Checked against the card: each settled pick gets one line with merged, PR, days, usd and signups; in-flight picks produce nothing; the sweep is…
Object. The test ungating is good, but the card's finish line is not met, and several card items are still open.
- Finish line not met. The dry venture tick on prod (
TIME_VENTURE=on,…
Object
I did not run the tests. The review is from the diff alone, and router.pick_cloud and tm.beats_of are not in it.
- astra.py,
router_tick,to_cloudloop (live branch):…
Object
The PR doesn't meet the card's finish line, and one of the card's three deliverables is missing.
- Finish line not met. The DONE criterion is that the server is reachable at the…
Approve
The diff matches card #97: a Node service on the MCP SDK, one placeholder tool, no disk/DB/secret access, and tests wired into CI. Both checks are green (ci / test and…
Object
The code is close, but I can't approve it as done yet. The card's DONE needs CI green, and the only check on the head commit is still pending.
- CI is not green.…
Object
The kit is a reasonable draft, but the PR should not merge as written. The card's finish line is not met, and the PR would close the card…